Audience reviews
20 · Sample from the first available page, separate from the total number of ratings.
AngeVNs
As someone who read (most) of the original visual novel it was based on and wasn't a huge fan... this anime adaptation of Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai was... mildly better, but barely?
Anime adaptations of visual novels (and well adaptations of anything) tend to mostly be used for advertising the original visual novel, and at least for me this anime was mostly better for one thing: actual good pacing. (if a bit fast at times)
The main problems I had with the visual novel were that it too slow paced, even for a slice of life heavy visual novel, AND most of the characters were boring. I could take maybe one of these issues if a VN eventually gets good but having both made the original VN a struggle.
Thankfully the anime had the decency to skim past a lot of the cringe stuff of the original v…
Read at the sourceMaxTheYukoner
#5
Everything about this anime screams "Fine". It's not really a standout, and to be honest, doesn't use the themes and idea's very effectively. The idea that a Shepard can see the future, was only used about twice in the show. It would've been better if that feature was touched on a bit more, and it's kind of a let down that it wasn't. A Good Librarian has fun characters, and the first episode was actually a great introduction. But, after that, it just wasn't the same. Even though the Shepard idea was cool, the significance of one just lurks in the shadow. The big "twist" is just eh, and kind of a throwaway. HOWEVER...
"Large Breasts are merely lumps of fat. Small Breasts are true beauty." -Kyotaro
A Fine harem anime that could've been more than what it turned out to be.
6/10
Read at the sourceB-O-D
When the series started, I wanted to like it but little niggly bits constantly started to annoy me. As it went on further and more episodes passed, so did my ratings of this show as i felt it showed plot holes.
The idea seems a good story, guardian angels of a sort are working in the background to give humanity its best chance without people ever knowing, yet somehow can email people and interact with them, even admitting they are these people with no actual oversight.
As time goes on we see these guardian angels willing to sacrifice one person, for another, and to me, I felt that went against the theme of the story, although it was made clear early on, the willingness to help those who will make a bigger difference, it felt off, how much they would potentially damage the future(which th…
Read at the sourcelolibolt
Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai was a good story that showed different types of characters and was more or less a stereotypical harem anime. The difference in this was one was that it gave a little something more on the harem plot and it was an interesting story.
Story: The story about all of the characters wanting to find themselves and become someone they want to be proud of is nice. Adding the romance on top of it helps it all go together quite nicely and gives something that was enjoyable.
Art: The art for this anime was good, I liked the designs of the characters a good amount and thought everything was visually appealing.
Sound: If anything this was the worst part about this anime, the sound quality was not the best, especially at the parts where Misono is singing, the audio seemed t…
Read at the sourcehexashadow13
tl;dr: A really good story that's a slice of life with interesting mechanics, but one that feels like it was only partially told in a rushed manner.
This anime is based off of a visual novel. At the end of the day, adapting a visual novel into an anime is a game of compromises. One of the advantages of a VN is that they're such a slow burn, building up characters and plot lines slowly in ways that feel natural and that get you really invested in the characters. It's pretty much impossible for an anime to have everything from a VN due to time constraints as well as a lot of things not translating that well to animation such as the structure or routes. Hence, adaptation comes down heavily to picking what to put in and what to leave out, with more than not generally left out. How these compr…
Read at the sourceanim_ai
Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai (A good librarian like a good shepherd) falls under a category I can only describe as "visual novel-y" (VNy). Within the first few minutes, I somehow knew there must be a VN of this somewhere (prior to writing this, I checked, and lo, there it was). You'll get the same feeling from "Shukufuku no Campanella" or "Koi to Senkyo to Chocolate", for instance. Anyway, this class of anime tends to be largely slice-of-life, with a comedic harem romance being the main attraction. Some kind of mystery is hinted at throughout the show, and in the last few episodes, some major plot events occur, and the hinted conflict is resolved.
Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai is, I think, a standard yet high quality addition to this category. It's a fairly calm and peaceful slice-of-life, with…
Read at the sourceAshiya-chan
Even if the Sepherd thing spices up the story, there was no good connection between this and the realife those students follow.
Maybe that happened because the anime is 12 ep long, and the only option was to cram it all up and make it shallow.
Pros:
The harem it was, I expected girls with a variety of personalities, just flirting with the main character, not evolving. Most of them learnt something with their interaction with him, and developed.
The main character wasn't a wuss, but a normal intellectual, although after the 3rd episode he started behaving like a typical boring, clueless, harem protagonist.
Cons:
The library environment was warm and cute, but there wasn't enough screen time to feel like you were there with them, even if the place was precious to them. So it ended up being j…
Read at the sourcetheotakuparade
a story simply curious but in the end a rather big disappointment, from a neutral point of view if the story had risen what it raised in the end would have been more interesting, the story begins with a fairly common development but progressing begins little by little to improve good until the chapter 7 where we put that lighting with such mediocre results that I hurt to see it, the series has enough decency in animation as soundtrack I find it very good people are quite direct but as they fall in love with our protagonist I found it easily bad, in conclusion a series of romance with comedy with an acceptable but demagrated story in my opinion would say that it has been a series of the heap
Read at the sourceTheRealNormie
Story- Had potential but, the characters never get developed. The romance is terrible. All the girls like the MC but, are to pansy to say it. They try to give them compelling stories that i didn't care for. You feel like it's going to turn into a harem but, we don't even get that. The real story is barely explained and can be completely ignored. The ending is very cheap and unsatisfying. 4/10
Art: Meh, slightly below average not amazing, but nothing to cry over. 4/10
Sound: Don't remember a single track (Just finished it 7 minutes ago) Sound effects were average. Great voice acting. 4/10
Characters: The only character's I found interesting were Nagi Kodachi,(Really funny and with a interesting past and Kyoutarou Kakei (Same) Every one else is to cookie cutter. Same boring tropes x10! MC…
Read at the sourceSlivko
In my anime List I rated 9 but overall objectivly I think its an 8.
This will be the most simple review that I will do in any anime I personaly reviewed.
So when I finished this anime wich was a few minutes when Im done with this review my first thoughts on it were "How did I missed this" cause it was just that good IMO. The story is interesting I think it focuses on some Japanese Folklore probably other cultures but lets say its Japanese on something called the Sheperd, and the Sheperd consists on some Transcendent Being that helps people be happy while taking control of theyr fate, cause they can see the future, past and everything a person has done when something is about to go wrong lets say an accident, the Sheperd takes action to save that person. All that Information are in books…
Read at the sourcedaimonfo
Its been a while since I wrote another "review". Oh well...
There is nothing wrong or right about this anime. Its another harem where MC is being liked by everyone and is the best because the writers said so. The story is sort of interesting and there is potential here, though I feel its squandered on the harem genre.
I liked the characters though there is nothing special about them. The MC is also nothing special, maybe the whole reading books is kind of cute, in a nerdy way. I like it, its nothing special.
You aren't missing much by not watching this, but its a cushion anime - made to comfortably fit around your fat ass. Its a comfort zone thing, like a bowl of chicken soup. Can't critique a bowl of hot soup for being bland when you got a cold right? I feel this anime is the same way.…
Read at the sourceVaenny
This series made me realize just how many harem series I've watched, to the point of knowing what the series was gonna end in just a few episodes. But for some reason, I enjoyed it a lot.
This was perhaps because of its concept of "having the ability to see the future" without anything relating to time travel. Also, its idea of becoming a being who can change the fate of a person to create a better world is not something anyone can come up of on the fly. I swear, this series had potential... if only it didn't become a harem series.
The reason why I think harem broke my interest for this series is because it didn't even need to have a harem tag in the first place. It would've been fine as simply "a boy who had the ability to change the fate of humans". But no, they just had to add that ta…
Read at the sourceWhipQueen
Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai is a cute slice of life series with a very interesting topic that is unfortunately not expanded on enough.
Story - 7/10
The story doesn't really develop much until the later episodes, and though it felt rushed I quite enjoyed the idea that the plot was trying to create. Unfortunately with as short as the show was, I felt like there wasn't enough time to fully enjoy it.
Art - 5/10
I must say that the artwork for the series did not stand out very much. Had it not been for the PV's I saw I might've skipped over the series without a second glance. There's nothing special about it.
Sound 6/10
The soundtrack also did not standout too much. The opening and ending songs were cute to say the least.
Character - 6/10
I give the characters a 6/10 because they were fai…
Read at the sourceZaku88
What would you do if you could sense the future? I don't mean the fake future as in Glasslip but the real future like in Kara no Kyoukai Mirai Fukuin. Well, in the world of Daitoshokan there is a secret Men In Black type organization that wields magic and can guide people to a "good" future. This organization of "shepherds" takes an interest in our particular protagonist, a bookworm named Kyoutarou, who happens to save an innocent bystander from a horrific future, and ends up conveniently fondling her in front of a massive crowd just for good measure.
Daitoshokan is the latest August work to be turned into an anime following Fortune Arterial. While the shows share some similarities (harem and school based slice of life elements), the story in Daitoshokan is much less organized and builds…
Read at the sourcereizenchuu
before i start talking about the story i need to clear out something: out of my own experience am sure most of you guys will get the wrong idea of the show when you'll see the anime's cover up there. because the first impression i got of the show when i saw it was another romcom harem that will end up as every harem series. not like it's not true but, there's still a genres tag missing that makes the anime more entertaining. and it is the Supernatural tag.
as most of you may know, the story is set in a prestigious high school academy with over 50000 students. and out of all this huge number, it follows our first main protagonist Kakei Kyoutarou a loner who enjoys reading books as his favorite passion.
however, he has a supernatural ability that lets him see the future of some people arou…
Read at the sourceesofdiamon
I watch this anime because I like anime about a bunch of cute schoolgirls with male lead as the center of attention. If you like Grisaia No Kajitsu you might like this but I doubt you will enjoying this because I think some of the episode are so so boring, and its totally different compared to serious Grisaia, this is a not-so-comedy anime. I intend to drop this anime since episode 10 but there is always something interesting happen towards the end so I cancel my decision and give this a try and to be honest its so tiresome. For me, a plot about a bookworm who wants to be a shepherd, a shepherd here mean a person who hold a book of fate of all people in the world and they have a power to change the fate. This is what the MC have here but I think this suppose to be main plot is just a subpl…
Read at the sourceOtaku_Buster
Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai is an anime about Shirasaki, an introvert girl who wants to create the "Happy Project" with the help of Kakei who she met in an inconvenient accident with a boob grab in front of the school. The accident happened due to Kakei's seeing the future power. With Kakei and Shirasaki meeting, the two embark a typical school life journey towards the completion of "Happy Project as they meet new friends. But here's the catch, a mysterious entity called the "Sheppard" stirs things up that either helps them or hinders them along the way.
Pros:
- Slice of life and Supernatural genre blended well in the plot
- fun characters (even the cat, which I think is the most interesting lol)
- minimal fanservice
- story pacing is smooth, not confusing
- a happy anime, you will always f…
Read at the sourcegilder1985
Initially, I'd written a review halfway through the show, now that I've completed it, here's an updated version.
Firstly, this is very much a slice of life show. If you're not a big fan of those, you may not want to watch this one. I enjoy slice of life, romance, comedy, fantasy, sci-fi, and other light-sided genre, so it appealed to me.
This show also incorporates a fantasy element - a magic library. I won't go into a lot of detail, so as not to ruin the story, but this library (while only briefly and periodically mentioned) is a theme that is important to every character in the show (but two, specifically). Your Main Character, Kakei, is seen having premonitions right from the get-go. He has this strange, but imperfected, ability - which he uses mostly to save people. The First girl he s…
Read at the sourceBanjoTheBear
(This has been adapted from my reddit thread)
During high school, it's a time to really start thinking about one's future: pursuing higher education, finding a part-time job, volunteer work, and extracurricular activities are all in the realm of setting one up for a successful life later down the road. Along the way, friends are made and decisions are chosen. Sometimes, though, teenagers need that tiny extra "push" to get them going down the right path. Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai will most definitely "be telling this with a sigh" that the path they took was "the one less traveled by."
**STORY**
Daitoshokan follows the life of Kakei, a young high school boy who, one day, saves Shirasaki from a fatal accident. Their newfound friendship causes them to form a group known as the Library Club.…
Read at the sourcePyraXadon
Ah, harems. One of the most subjective anime genres that exists, as well as one of those that can be both hit or miss. On this review, I'll b talking about Daitohokan no Hitsujikai which...falls into the latter.
Story (5.11/10): The story of Daitoshokan, or "A good librarian like a good shepherd", a boy by the name of Kakei Kyotaro enters a prestigious school with the thought of going to school and sort of delving into the crowd, spending his time in his books. However, one day, he meets a girl by the name of Shirasaki Tsugumi, and gets invited to her little plan called the "Shiomi Happy Project", in attempt to make the school a wonderful place.
I'll be blunt here. The story is shit. And that's kinda putting it lightly. Like a lot of anime, the show does have a bit of a decent start to i…
Read at the source
