Audience reviews
20 · Sample from the first available page, separate from the total number of ratings.
Gyaruicide
This story is so poorly written and the anime so poorly produced that it flips around to being an absolute riot to watch.
Here are some quick plot points:
- The main character is an amateur light novel author but his work doesn't win any competitions because he sucks at writing
- His prototypical prim and perfect younger sister, who seems really annoyed and dismissive of his existence, writes a beautiful and touching light novel which immediately wins first place in the coveted newcomer author competition
- Their father will get pissed if he finds out she's writing when she should be focusing on school, so she asks him to pretend to be the author
- The light novel blows up in popularity so the sister asks the MC to pretend to be the author, causing the bulk of the comedic situations with…
Read at the sourceFranqitoH
Okay, here we go for the forty-sixth time:
Characters:
-Main characters: I don't know if the protagonist is incestuous or not, but at least his younger sister provided some funny moments. (3/7)
-Supporting characters: What they did to Esaka is unforgivable... (1/3)
Logic:
It's unclear whether the protagonist is incestuous or not, women join the harem for no reason, it makes no sense that the protagonist seems unaware of his younger sister's feelings, the protagonist doesn't know if he has parents or maybe I don't remember, so many illegal things, the protagonist receives advice and out of nowhere his writing skills are comparable to the most popular works on the market in this world, I honestly don't know what's illogical about this anime. (3/10)
Entertainment (Personal):
Having 10 epi…
Read at the sourceYusufBulunmaz
As soon as I saw the title and the cute little sister, I jumped into the anime with all my enthusiasm. I hadn't expected much, as I already had a good idea of what would happen and it did.
The main character constantly acts cowardly and dunderhead. It's not that I’m unfamiliar with characters like this, but every time I encounter such nonsense, I question why the protagonist can't go further, especially when it comes to romantic development. Also he uses -san honorific when he adresses Suzuka.That said, it's clear that our MC has feelings of love and lust for his little sister, which is evident from his reactions. This aspect counters his timid nature to some extent.
The plot revolves around the little sister, Suzuka, who writes a light novel and enters it in an online contest, eventuall…
Read at the sourceSmilomaniac
I don't know what the light novel or manga is like, but man was the author done dirty by absolutely subpar animation, direction, editing and acting. It may be that the novel was never that good to begin with, but it was definitely made worse by this anime. It sort of feels like two seasons squeezed into 12 episodes sometimes.
I'll skip the story summary (it's a sister moe/harem romcom) and get right to the point: Is this worth spending your time on? For most people, no it doesn't meet the standard of animation of 2018, but if you can look past the amateur animation and directing, the story isn't that bad and the conclusion to the story's final hurdle is kind of fun, which is why I give this a '5' and not less.
There are some story points, characters and ideas worth thinking about and exp…
Read at the sourceWAIFSTON
(NO SPOILERS!)
Bro, this is far more good than you may even think, DO NOT ever listen to the bloody edge lords.
It's good. Just good. Enjoy the trip. When you watch this, you feel yourself being on a cruise ship, you do not think much or feel much, but that's the bloody point. It's good, clean and good.
Wierd idea to write a lot of words, what is, essay, lol? Just don't listen to the edge lords and play the anime.
Review rating : 10/10. Yes.
The story is this:
"
Aspiring light novel author Yuu Nagami regularly enters writing competitions but has yet to win a single one. Despite his recurring failures, he remains steadfast in his resolve to become a better writer.
When he takes a look at the list of winning authors in the latest contest he joined, he notices that someone named Chikai Tow…
Read at the sourceziratrugar
Holy hell. What a chore to watch. This is one of those shows that starts with an interesting premise, but then completely abandons it and all logic for constant fan-service and bad jokes. This was an incredibly difficult show to finish.
The main characters are your basic brother/sister complex pair. The side characters are annoying and forgettable. I honestly don't think I liked anyone in this show. It was a chore getting through the endless bad attempts as humor and the creation of conflict.
The worst part though was the art. I'm not an animation snob. I don't need Bones to animate a show in order to be able to enjoy it. But if the art in a show sucks, it's very noticeable. It's like when you have a bad offensive line in football. When their names aren't being called, you know they're d…
Read at the sourceDennis_King
My sister, My writer, My life that slowly faded away and like dust in the wind was scattered all over the mountains of despair where my loved ones mourned my passing, while my coffin was, slowly but steadily, going down to my final resting place, where maggots would feast on my dead flesh and demons would rape my soul in hell for eternity....Death was only the beginning....
And death would be a nice change of pace in this instance, where i find my self reviewing and at the same time warning people not to fall for this trap..If i make no sense or my grammar has gone to shit FUCK YOU i'm trying to turn my liver into ash and in the process forget i ever saw this shit. In fact i'd rather be bound and gagged and then raped by Cthulu hmself.
So...This anime is about incest...Well Japan duh....…
Read at the sourceNextUniverse
Before I start, shoutout to 正直困太.
I honestly have no intention of making a long review. I think the score does a good job at what you need to know will go down here, or maybe it doesn't? Which makes this review for you I suppose. I must point out as well that I do like to be a voice of reason (the irony). For some purpose, the community goes and throws extreme numbers against widely criticised anime and don't shine a light on the good aspects (or say that what is existing isn't appalling, just bad). To each their own with rating and whatnot, but it doesn't correlate to a general audience viewpoint, which seems a little inconvenient. Anyways, I would like to provide an unbiased outlook on "My Sister, My Writer".
The story here isn't bad, more so incredibly boring, cliche, and downright a…
Read at the sourceSilentfan6
Listen, you'll find a lot of reviews talking about how bad this anime is, but I want to make this perfectly clear. I was genuinely impressed with the full asses and thick thighs that at least two of the girls in this anime are sporting. Like, normally you'd get the super skinny or the loli, but no, these girls are so normal it's refreshing.
All hail Sakura and Reika's beautiful butts!!
Ahem, that said, this anime is definitely not the worst I've seen, and the reviews that convey that severely negative statement are quite surprising. I will admit though that it is shabby and the animation isn't consistent (seriously, just look at their eyes and see how much they change). This anime may also be severely cliche, but it felt like a nice sugary candy. Harmless and enjoyable.
The basic premi…
Read at the sourceLLCritler
Oh my lord where should I start?
One of the best Ecchi I have watched without a doubt. Nothin can be compaared to this Masterpiece.
The Soundtracks are on-point probably the best thing the anime industrie had seen. The soundtracks were always used on proper situations also the choice was almost perfect. 10/10.
Story is a bit unusal thats why I enyoed it so much. It has a clear and complex storyline. Ecchi, emotions, onii-chan what do you want more? 10/10
oh man oh man let me say somthing. The drawings are incredible high quality but the mouth movement could be more accurate 9/10
Overall I like this anime, people might say I have a trash taste but lets be honest, if we are going to watch shit i expect shit. And because of that i love this piece of art <3.
This review is a trash review…
Read at the sourceStarAlone
Because i only write review when something really hits me in anime differently from others, bad or good thing, i didn't write many, but this was one of those few cases..... but i really don't feel that there is a lot to explain so it will be a short one.
(free of spoilers)
At this point i watched many titles and my bar of quality is much lower to start an anime. As i enjoy also mix up of genre as "Ore ga Suki nano ha Imouto.." served us, i gave it a try... should you? if you watched few hundreds of titles, you can give it a try but it might not be worth it, even if your bar is lower too.
To be honest, i can't give it 1/10 like many people did. I'll say more, story isn't original at all (but what do you expect :V), art is on level of standard budget anime quality, but characters were like…
Read at the sourcesurcuel
After I watch this anime. I like the storyline.. its not bored at all. Seems pretty fun. I like the character design. And all of the seiyuu's are the best. I enjoy this so much. But I think the man character need more giving his love for his imouto. I'am not a siscon.
For another reason why like this anime:
It's because I love they eyes. Like it's familiar but it's not.
I like this anime because this is not Harem. But I think the ova it's harem.
I wrote this review for you guys, who like to have a little sister. But you don't. Or you have but... You know.
I watched the ova version too, but I think the ova version it's not that good as the TV version. Because in the ova they playing game and.. being harem or I don't know..
Read at the sourceTobias2499
Now, first of all, I think we all can agree on the fact, that all of these 'teased incest' animes are 'special'. However, for some of those there is actually a story behind it and behind the shell of 'Look, it's about incest' they can be decent.
However, that is NOT the case for this one. The story is nothing special. However, i've seen worse.
Art is not good. At certain points the characters look so insanely bad, it feels like they wanted this anime to be a failure.
Sound. Well, I don't remember a single song from this anime. However that just means that the music is nothing special at all. In good cases aswell in bad.
Characters. The characters have next to no personality at all. There is like one character or so, that you get some backround information on but that's it.
The MC is a…
Read at the sourcerobert788
Ore ga Suki nano wa Imouto dakedo Imouto ja Nai (2018)
STORY:
A beautiful sister and an average brother who live in a general life. The brother wants to be an author and the sister is a model student. She is also a Bro-Con which is made very apparent. Due to her school rules and the backlash potential she has her brother who isn’t a very good writer stand in for her when she submits a novel which is about her, and wins (secretly without telling the brother that it is about her desires). He then gains a harem situation of people who admire his work for the good and bad reasons with him and the sister keeping the truth hidden. As the story progresses feelings become stronger until a climax. It is somewhat similar to Eromanga-sensei is many aspects of the basic story and the archetype of t…
Read at the sourceMaster303
This is my first time writing a review, so it's probably lacking.
Rated 2 Story - The story was kinda there, there are 2 critical problems, one is the fact that as a responsible student council president, Suzuka, isn't allowed to have a part-time job, which is against school rules, making no sense. The second problem includes a never-to-be-mentioned OR seen father that would, "will most certainly be against it." All we ever saw of this father was a blacked-out silhouette, and he is never talked about after this huge "obstacle". These two problems that start this whole story are never to be talked about again and are never an actual trouble throughout the story. There was no apparent plot, it was more of a cliché to force these two to come together.
Rated 4 - Art - The art was the only g…
Read at the sourceInfrasonic
I've seen/read one or two incest anime/manga in the past. Oreimo and Eromanga Sensei are the most popular ones. In fact, I'm somebody who didn't think Eromanga Sensei was a total pile of steaming crap. Sure, it did have questionable content, but overall, it wasn't the worst thing I've ever seen.
This series? It's probably the worst I've seen. Both out of incest anime and overall.
I guess this review does have spoilers, but there isn't much to spoil in a storyless anime like this.
Story...?
You're probably expecting a story. I guess there is one? You have a brocon imouto who writes a light novel that goes famous. It's, surprise surprise, a brocon novel. But since she's a model student she can't be the author of that novel otherwise she'd get expelled. So you have aspiring novelist brother…
Read at the sourceSaku_k
There are a lot of negative reviews for this series, so I wanted to provide my own input.
This show is absolutely HILARIOUS. I feel a lot of people are watching this show for the wrong reasons. Yes the story is bad. Yes the characters are 2 dimensional. But again, the comedy is top notch.
The art is just incredible. The main heroine (the imouto) will go from looking like 10 different people within the same episode. Her face will melt between a cute as heck little sister to a cross-eyed goblin, and it is amazing. She will be on her bed with a normal pillow, then the next second the pillow has become a gigantic shark pillow. She will be in the most awkward, physically unnatural poses, and I just can't stop laughing.
As if that isn't enough, the over the top voice acting, for the mostly abs…
Read at the sourceSnoopy25
I can't give extremely poor overall ratings, but there were some serious flaws here that need to be addressed.
Overall, the anime was enjoyable, can't argue there. It gave a few laughs, has enough eye candy for the ecchi-hearted people. The character voicing wasn't annoying (as is in some anime). But good GOD the character design was awful... There are certain angles that the animation studio could not get right for the life of them... For some reason side shots look fine, but straight-on shots look absolutely horrendous. But at the same time, there's certain scenes where the straight-facing characters look completely normal and well made. It's like they split the work among different departments and they all animated certain sections and put the thing together. Some failed harder than ot…
Read at the sourcealexg2222
Ironically, this show has the same problem as the MC has, he can not create something entertaining. The show was utterly boring, nothing kept me hooked , no suspanse, same old bulshit typical Male MC,useless, no courage, nice guy all the time to everyone type, not even any development, same with the relationship of the 2 main characters, their relationship is still the same as it was in the beginning, even the moments they tried to make to be heart warming were really crappy. The character design was okay, although on more than 1 episode i saw some really bad animation, but we can get past that. Overall in my opinion, this show was a waste of time, don't want to insult the ones who created the show, i know they put a lot of work in it, but the truth of the matter is, it sucked.
Read at the sourceMarkhiel
Introduction to the analysis and review:
"guilty pleasure" simply is not enough to describe the feeling of watching this peace of cr*p. I felt i worth less as a human being during each episode I watched. The cliché story, the pathetic animation and character design, the ridiculous way the situations developed.. everything felt as the staff was mocking at the spectator. And yet, I could not stop watching. This may be a show for masochists. I'm sure of it. so let's talk about the individual elements:
Story: It is a cheap copy of Eromanga Sensei, the diference is that the main character is a failure, instead of a well succeeded writer, and that the imouto is a real imouto, not a step sister, and she is a good writer, instead of being a good drawer. Exception to it, it's completely equal in id…
Read at the source
