Audience reviews
20 · Sample from the first available page, separate from the total number of ratings.
KimuraTheHatoru
Even Given the Worthless "Appraiser" Class, I’m Actually the Strongest trully doesn't leave anything to the imagination.And im not saying that as a compliment.For people who just want the verdict .... TLDR:it's cliche,it's barely mid to be honest. For people intrested in details let's get into it:
Now the premise of this show isn't that bad,but it's handled in one of the worst ways possible. This show might not be an isekai,but it really took the worst parts of one and rolled with it. Including the low tier animation.There's no frames i can praise in this entire show.Every fight felt lackluster with barely any movement.And while the animation mostly does that,this is also because the MC is OP. No fight is truly a struggle.
And since we are talking about the MC,let's get into how he fare…
Read at the sourceuser21557117
Story: The story is a somewhat generic power fantasy and harem story, which is to say not that interesting. It is however better than the average slice of life or romance anime so I will give it that. I'll give the story a 4/10 and that's mostly because things actually happen and it feels somewhat interesting.
Art style and animation: The animation is pretty standard, not super cheap nor super flashy and high quality. So I'd say it's average in that regard.
Characters: The characters were alright, not super full of personality and somewhat one dimensional. Not of them really made me laugh. The art style for them is slightly odd, the outfits look better than most fantasy anime outfits but the way the humans are draw just looks too fake and off. And I know it's a japanese thing but it was…
Read at the sourceLabo987
if you go into this show expecting to watch the next aot with crazy plot and character development you will be disappointed but if you go into this show expecting a light watch and to watch something filled with fun yet still interesting characters it’s for you.
it does follow all the generic genre paradigms of a fantasy/adventure show but what i think it does better then most of the same shows is that the characters are very loveable and it’s a good funny show to watch. The plot is very thin and straightforward but it does get you hooked and wanting to know what happens next and the man idea of the plot very interesting and exciting.
The main Mc is a good character who funny at most times. The other MCs being the sisters are funny and the interactions between the sisters and the sister…
Read at the sourcepinkaze
As overpowered, as overpowered go. So much so that I would rate lower if that's the basis. But hey, I actually liked the characters so I enjoyed the whole thing!
MC's appraisal skill became so overpowered he can predict moves AND copy all skills/spells simply by appraising.
This happened because his eye is made up of the core of Yuri, one of the nine spirits of yggdrasil scattered around the world. In exchange, he promised to reunite Yuri will all her sisters. And every sister they find, they turn into a companion.
So 9 sisters... You'd think that's a HUUUGE number of characters to collect. But wait til I tell you, every yggdrasil spirit has a guardian. So multiply that by 2 😂 Include a king, a princess, a merchant, guild master, townspeople, villains, and goodness, there are so many c…
Read at the sourceAnimeW33b_172
Even Given the Worthless “Appraiser” Class, I’m Actually the Strongest, it was a great anime.
I would give it a 10 with how the story is played out and how characters are introduced plus with each new character having their own interesting ability which contributes to him being the strongest, each character is fun in their own way while contributing something. This anime is a masterpiece and I can't wait for another season!
The anime is fairly similar to others in it's kind of genre the harem and fantasy genres being the most alike to others but, the way that the characters are brought about is very well done.
it's not rushed nor too slow, it also wasn't boring at any point. If someone says that it's bad because of the genre being Harem and Fantasy then what did you expect most people pr…
Read at the sourcelittlejimmy134
Generic, unoriginal, copy and paste garbage. This is another one of these shows where the main character has no growth and is overpowered. Yes, he starts out weak, but quickly becomes overpowered in the first or second episode. He has no challenges and their are no real fights. They hype up dragons and demons, but nothing actually poses a threat to him. There isn't even a redeeming quality in this show. The show isn't funny. There are no compelling stories. Characters feel lifeless. There's no emotion. I was so fed up by the last episode that I just hit the right arrow key to skip quickly through it. The story would have been better if he got ate by the dogs in the first episode.
Read at the sourceTurtezin
I started watching this back when it aired in early January, gave it three episodes, called it trash with a 4/10, and moved on. At least, that was the plan. But lately, YouTube kept throwing shorts from this show at me, so I gave it another chance. You know what? Bad idea.
When it comes to story depth, this anime is about as deep as a puddle. It crams in every overused trope you can think of—harem, overpowered MC, human vs. demon conflict—but executes them so poorly it’s almost impressive. And of course, our main character has a heart of gold despite being treated like garbage his whole life. Believable? Not at all.
Artstyle and animation are equally uninspired. Mediocre at best, and nothing worth praising.
Overall, even if you’re bored, I can’t recommend this one. There are far better…
Read at the sourceDestron
This anime was one of the rare times I watched every single episode in 1 sitting. For the last few weeks I've been in a bit of a slump with anime. Lately I haven't found any that I've fully enjoyed with the exception of the seasonal anime currently going on but Even Given the Worthless "Appraiser" Class, I’m Actually the Strongest managed to make me watch it start to finish and enjoy every moment of it.
I can see why this anime seems to be very mixed with the community. On the surface it comes across as another generic ass fantasy anime in which the main character starts off weak and within the span of like 30 minutes becomes ridiculously over powered and can defeat any monster in one hit. And for the most part, that is how it begins. Maybe I'm just that de-sensitized to it at this point…
Read at the sourceMoehiza
Watching this anime felt like meeting someone new. At first, they seemed great, but the more I got to know them, the more their bad sides showed. This anime was exactly the same. When I first watched the first 3 episodes, I was quite interested in the story. However, as I continued watching, I started to feel weird about it and grew to dislike the story. I still don't understand why the MC, with his appraisal skill, even decided to become an adventurer. Someone with a skill like that just isn't cut out to be an adventurer. Why didn't he just become a merchant if all he wanted was to change his life? I simply couldn't grasp the MC's motivation for becoming an adventurer. Then, the further I watched, the more I got fed up with the MC's incredibly naïve personality.
The visuals themselves ar…
Read at the sourceUncleDandy
Starts out semi promising then turns into yet another worthless beta b!tch MC won't kill the purely evil characters no matter what regardless of how much evil and literal child sacrifice they commit in from of him. If you are some kind of brain dead Canadian who thinks that "If you kill you enimies they win" then you will love this show. More info because the sh!t ass review system won't let me publish the actual minimun you need to know: Characters are all flat and have no growth throughout the show. As a harem anime the fanservice is lacking greatly with nothing titilating being shown and as the MC is a dense retard who cannot figure out even the most overt of advances on him zero progress happens on any of the possible relationship fronts.
Read at the sourcedeijiplays
The story was predictable. I had hoped it would be fresh and exciting since it premiered in 2025. However, throughout all 12 episodes, it remained predictable. Many anime had a similar plot where the main character was powerful and defeated the villains after being reincarnated, revived, or surviving a serious tragedy. Even within this familiar setup, there were usually a few unique scenes or traits. I knew the title suggested predictability, but I still watched it, expecting something different. In the end, it was just as I thought: predictable.
Eins survived a personal tragedy and became stronger thanks to a girl who supported him on his journey. His real strength came from the girls he met along the way. His adventure began when one girl fell in love with him, giving him the strength h…
Read at the sourceAsdfaeou
My god was this a tragedy. Genuinely interesting first two? episodes laying out the character and then the powers he gains in what I felt was a pretty unique setting and situation!
Then it immediately descended into worthless horny drivel of every single breathing thing around the MC throwing themselves endless at the MC with an unending list of anime tropes. Feels like the makers had a concept and nothing else and just needed to get their rocks off fanaticizing for themselves. They've set up for a season two, which I strongly hope does not occur.
They give the MC a background, and you understand who he is and why he is the way he is, but they also abandon that hierarchy except for one mention in an episode about midway in, and even at that point, the plot point is forgotten due to the…
Read at the sourceVeryISFJ
Plot/Story: Quite stale tbh. I mean this is one of those OP MC anime, which usually doesn't really have a good plot which is fine and you just watch it for the OPness. But this one I feel like it's trying to be both, which results in it being half baked. Not very enjoyable OP power/MC, and not very good plot. 5/10.
Animation: Not the worst, like not as bad as The New Gate. But the animation in fights is awkward and doesn't look fluid, aka lazy animation. Even the normal animation outside fights feels a bit wonky. 5/10.
Cringe: Has some moments where it feels very cringey. Like the MCs interaction with the girls. The cringiness I wouldn't say is as bad as Tensei Kizoku no Isekai Boukenroku: Jichou wo Shiranai Kamigami no Shito. If the cringiness in Tensei Kizoku no Isekai Boukenroku: Jich…
Read at the sourceChuy_diazz
The best thing about this anime is the character design... and that's it.
Another fantasy harem story hitting our screens. I'd honestly like to try my best to find at least two or three reasons why you should give it a chance, but I can't list more than one. That's the biggest sign that watching this anime might be more of a waste of time than a pleasant afternoon. The first two episodes try to be a story with more blood than average, but the blood only lasts in those episodes. Later on, this aspect isn't relevant. The protagonist starts by giving us something different, having to reshape his body to get used to the powerful abilities he's acquiring, but once again, this only lasts in the initial part of the anime.
The highlight and the only good reason I have to recommend it is the char…
Read at the sourceyasyaa
This anime is quite good, especially if you're a fan of the harem genre. As expected, it follows the usual tropes, but that doesn't make it any less enjoyable. The characters are incredibly cute and add a lot of charm to the story. Their interactions, comedic moments, and distinct personalities make the anime fun to watch. The storyline itself is decent, though I find it a bit predictable. It doesn’t bring anything particularly new or groundbreaking to the genre, but it still manages to entertain. The pacing is smooth, and the episodes flow nicely, making it an easy watch without feeling too slow or rushed. Visually, the animation is vibrant, and the character designs are appealing. The voice acting is also well done, enhancing each character’s personality and making their emotions more en…
Read at the sourceSorreah
The show was pretty good up until he went full Pollyanna. I'm not saying he couldn't be idealistic or had to be edgy, but there should be a limit to how campy someone is. It just got annoying to watch, not because the action was bad, but the MC just kept doubling down on the "I need to be a good person and save everyone because I was helped and saved!"
...somehow this review needs more information, and the suggested bullets are all things I already addressed.
-It's not unique, but its fine in that it follows the get an OP power trope
-The art is fine
-The characters were disappointing. The sisters all seem to embody a "moe" trope and the MC doubles and triples down on the "I've got to use my power to be a good person!" to the point of obnoxiousness
-It started out realistic with showing o…
Read at the sourceNoLongerAtsushi
At first, I was excited, and the anime really seemed promising. Then the creators decided to bombard us with a ridiculously huge amount of unfunny jokes and embarrassing behavior from every character. I don’t even feel like mentioning the MC, who’s trying to be the new Tanjiro. If anyone gives this anime more than a 5/10, it's probably just because of the ecchi nothing else. The only thing that could have changed my opinion would be an ending where the goddesses, after using the MC to the fullest, finally end his life, but that didn’t happen. For me, it’s a 3/10.
Read at the sourceAnime-Isekai-God
Now that this anime has come to an end
I'll say that this been an amazing ride.
We saw Ein each ep rebuild his character greater and greater, becoming an overall better and stronger person with the full support of those he loves and those that love him as more and more spirits enter his lives as he saves them and reunites them with their sisters. This isn't just a character development for Ein but also for everyone, Ursula, Yuri, Pina, Kursh, Akahane, Kurohime,
Alice, and lastly May in many ways more or less.
Now not sure why this anime is getting all these negative reviews that 100% isn't deserving of, either they haven't been paying attention or drop it early on. EIther way I beg to differ with their mere opinions.
10/10 Cannot wait for S2 to come bout
Read at the sourceComet_Official
So I just finished this anime and although I did a review initially after 6 episodes I wanted to update my thoughts. I must say even though the concept of this show has done before Even Given the Worthless Appraisal Class has a unique and fun environment in which it accomplishes its story. In classic fashion we have an MC who's skill is deemed worthless by society as a whole, he is betrayed and in turn gets stronger as a result of his skill not being so worthless after all. What is unique about this story is it focuses on a skill or class most anime fans have seen in one form or another, the Appraisal skill. In most anime stories this skill is almost EXCLUSIVELY a support skill or job where you are never in harms way. With this story we get to see our MC use this skill in combat not only t…
Read at the sourceKANLen09
Even Given the Worthless "Appraiser" Class, I’m Actually the Strongest — Can we be done with these so-called "weak" classes that are OP as heck but paired with what I can tell is the most egregious choice of picking an even worse MC?
"Turn off your brain and just enjoy the ride, no matter how truly good or bad it is." Don't you feel that lots of people have been calling shows as is and think that they can emit the same feelings as you do? It's definitely annoying, yes, but this repetitive trope will never go away for shows that "feel" like they deserve the quote above but end up being severely underwhelming, so there's no justification to prove otherwise. Case in point, novelist Ibarakino's Fuguushoku "Kanteishi" ga Jitsu wa Saikyou Datta: Naraku de Kitaeta Saikyou no "Shingan" de Musou s…
Read at the source