Audience reviews
20 · Sample from the first available page, separate from the total number of ratings.
Pinoos
ID :
"Salah Paham" kayanya judul yang pas sih ya buat animenya wkwkwk, ceritanya mungkin emang bukan sesuatu yang baru buat cerita kerajaan kaya gini tapi lumayan asik buat ditonton. Komedinya juga menurutku ga cringe jadi bisa ditonton enjoy, bagian romancenya juga lumayan banyak yang lucu-lucu walau kerasanya masih kurang sih. Bener-bener ngeliatin perjuangan Mia buat mengubah takdir dia dengan memperbaiki semua masalah di masa lalunya, dan endingnya juga yang termasuknya ga gantung jadi bisa ditutup dengan tenang.
Diliat dari segi grafik, enak buat ditonton dan ga terlalu berlebihan, dan kadang dia ngasih ekspresi muka yang lucu kaya terlalu di anime animekan. Menurutku bukan hal jelek dan suka-suka aja ngeliatnya jadi gaada masalah. Sifat dari karakternya juga yang pengikut setia buat…
Read at the sourceJonaRM
I quite liked the first part; the idea is good, but the episodes become repetitive, and when they try to advance the plot, it feels out of place with what's already been shown, like they just wanted to give it a proper ending.
It's fine if you want to watch it, but I don't think you'll learn anything from it. It's just for a bit of entertainment, that's all.
I feel like they could have explored the romance genre much more deeply. It had more potential. The fights were rather boring and didn't hold my interest.
Even so, I appreciated that the characters weren't annoying, but I think that for how intelligent they were supposed to be, they ended up being somewhat foolish. I think I expected much more from this anime based on the first few episodes, and I ended up disappointed.
Read at the sourceexviudc
It's been a while since I cringed this hard while watching a show. The premise seemed interesting at first, but the anime caters to the lowest common denominator, as expected of this kind of story.
The show is childish, the main character is dumb and annoying. Even though she was older by the time she was executed in her first life, it seems she forgot everything and reverted to the mind of an 8-year-old in her second life. She acts like a typical tsundere and the comedic moments are painfully cringe. The narrator also always explains to the viewer when she acts one way but was thinking otherwise, as if it wasn't plain obvious already.
She doesn't plan anything, yet everyone magically treats her like a saintly genius and everything works out in the end. There are no stakes. All the char…
Read at the source1Crazyplayer
If you like other light hearted comedic villainess anime, this is the anime for you.
Tearmoon Teikoku is exactly what you see you get. The first half of the anime is very well done in that classic villainess comedic style, while incorporating and taking inspiration from events during the French Revolution. The later episodes where it starts to diverge and rely on it's own storytelling start off strong, but in the closing episodes on the second watch through I noticed how they just don't explain why certain characters are in the places they are. So that part was confusing. Overall it's a solid option if you're villainess starved.
Read at the sourcepinkaze
It's unique in the sense that it's not a "reincarnated into a villainess" but rather villainess reborn to her younger self.
Some people found that premise refreshing, but to be honest, for the first few episodes, all I could think of was she didn't deserve the second chance lol.
Other than that, i have no other problems. It's a feel good anime like the other villainess ones. It's good but not super unique. I've watched a lot of villainess anime by now so I'm used to the common tropes. But i still found this quite enjoyable.
I like the comedy that arises from the misunderstandings that she is a genius. There are plenty of moments that gave me a good laugh.
All in all, it is a fun watch.
Read at the sourcePro-Anime-Review
This series immediately caught my attention with its intriguing premise. From the very first episode, I found myself drawn in by the setup and the promise of a story that revolves around themes of character redemption. I’ve seen this kind of “going back in time” concept used before, and more often than not, those stories tend to collapse under their own weight as they progress. That expectation had me a bit cautious, but this show quickly proved that it was handling the idea with far more skill and nuance than most.
What makes this series stand out is the way it executes its time-reset concept through both its storytelling and its characters. Watching the main character navigate each situation feels engaging, and there’s a genuine sense of growth woven into the narrative, although sometim…
Read at the sourceBocchiTheRacist
Tearmoon Empire begins with a clever satirical premise—what if Marie Antoinette got a second chance at life, but only to save her own neck? That’s the situation Princess Mia finds herself in, after being executed by revolutionaries and waking up in her younger body. Her attempts to selfishly avoid her future fate are hilariously misinterpreted as acts of wisdom and kindness, setting off a chain of events that reshape the empire around her. The series plays this twist for comedy, leaning more toward light satire than serious political drama.
The comedy is quite enjoyable and often smart, but it comes at a cost. While the world-building is solid and hints at deeper systemic issues within the empire, the anime simplifies much of what the light novel explores with more nuance. Some character…
Read at the sourceCynthesia
Yet another drop in the reincarnation/time travel/Akuyaku Reijou barrel of shows which grows increasingly large with every season. Tearmoon Empire primarily suffers from an overwhelming lack of focus in what exactly it wants to do as well as an extremely weak leading character.
We follow Mia Tearmoon, a haughty princess who is executed due to a revolution brought upon poor leadership from the noble ruling class. She returns to her past self along with a magic diary containing her memories from the revolution as well as her years in solitary confinement. The course of the story follows Mia as she makes attempts to fix her kingdom and improve her social standing as to avoid her ultimate demise at the guillotine.
This is all well and good but Tearmoon Empire made an interesting decision w…
Read at the sourcepfeil
The first episode of this, in particular, was a tour de force of exactly how to set up a show like this. After a bunch of reincarnation shows that fumble the beginning -- looking at you, Solo Leveling -- it was wonderful to watch this one. Not overstaying the before-the-hook, a good use of flashbacks later for the bits we need, strong character interactions that show us what to expect going forward, etc.
Then it does a great job of Mia trying her best to fix stuff, but not really knowing how to do that, but having others comedically misunderstand her in a way that works well. The extra "they beheaded me!" part works well for turning what could have been a generic "oh look, another elite school" setting into something enjoyable. Even little things like her joining the riding club because s…
Read at the sourceSgtSalamander
Tearmoon Empire is a fascinating tale of political intrigue, the life of nobility, and one precocious young woman's second chance at life. It presents an engaging mix of weighty political considerations, their moral implications, and the charming, lighthearted life of young aristocrats, presented as they come through the eyes of a spoiled princess with the weight of the world on her shoulders. Beginning with the story, which is this anime's strongest aspect, it is safe to say I was duly impressed. Not only does it amount to an honest and genuine consideration of monarchism as a political system, and could honestly be considered as a kind of modern-day treatise on enlightened despotism, it also manages to handle both the heavy subject of good governance in the face of bloody revolution and…
Read at the sourceEleaB
Recommended for those who like transmigration/rebirth type anime, this one FL travels back to a few years before her tragic death at the guillotine. It wasn't amazing, but I liked it more than I thought it would. But then again as many other similar animes, you can only truly enjoy this when you don't try to think about the details of the plot - e.g. why the heck does a 12/14 yr old princess have the power to make so many important decisions?
Nonetheless, I like that FL's love-interest isn't the obvious perfect Prince Sion, it's actually the not-so-perfect but super adorable Prince Abel. That alone got me interested enough to watch the entire anime series. So we've got an FL that appears to be super smart and wise to everyone, but she's actually just planning how to not get her own head…
Read at the sourceVrozty
[Very shocking intensity of the first episode leads to hilarious enlightenment as she lives her second life in the rest of the episodes. —10/10]
Tearmoon Empire is a story of second chance. The plot is centered towards Princess Mia's new life as she got enlightenment from her previous devastating life. The first episode was so shockingly intense, but not to worry! The rest of the episodes are truly what Tearmoon Empire is all about — just a girl giving everyone second chances as she was given one herself! It is a story about learning, about opening possibilities, and choosing love (although the anime depicted Princess Mia's motivations as purely selfish and survival-based). However, all this heartwarming qualities are all so packed with comedy, comedy, and comedy!
I just can't stop sayin…
Read at the sourceZeno_Artaxerxes
Marie Antoinette if she was still young and got a second chance at life knowing what happens (at least the version of Marie that we all heard of).
This anime is a comedy that started from some serious moments, which also just fuels the comedy part, where a selfish princess is mistaken as a genius by everyone around her, even though her genius is mostly a God level luck, and for real you're gonna see that luck in play a lot during the show. She does/thinks something for a really selfish or dumb reason, but it leads to the right outcome and the people around her overthink the hell out of everything she does... But she tries her best to go with it... Quite a few "conincidences" that are in her favor... Luck-kun (or is it Plot Armor-kun?) working overtime here for her, fr
It's a feel good sh…
Read at the sourceSassyBug
I have not read the manga so this is strictly my perspective from the anime.
If you are a fan of the reformed villainess genre this is most likely up your alley.
The story is not trying to set it's self above or apart from the rest of it's genre it is simply a fun, lighthearted villainess story with elements of Dr. Elise, I Shall Survive Using Potions, and 80,000 Gold in Another World that fans of the genre will enjoy.
This is not intended to be deeply emotional or complex; it is intended to make to laugh at the antics, follies, and misunderstandings of the characters as our villainess does everything she can to try and change her fate.
It has no bad language, nsfw, or fanservice; it does however have an adorable budding romance and I really hope it gets another season.
Read at the sourceYamiWatcher
Tearmoon is a light-hearted fun take on the villainess/otome genre. The show focuses heavier on comedy than anything else, but it has enough sprinkles of strategy, politics, drama and other things we would expect from a princess show.
The real strength of this show is that it is a fun delve into these things rather than a serious one, but that may also serve as it's weakness. Tearmoon does not get too caught up in any big arcs or large plots. However, it is quite nice to see what happens, as because of the nature of Princess Mia, things do not always go quite as planned, or as you may of thought.
I think it's important to note that this will not be a show most people will give a 9 or 10, and it does not have amazing production value, but it is still a fun delve into this genre, and if…
Read at the sourcePixelB
If the Tearmoon Kingdom novel series is a 10/10, then I'd give the anime adaption a 5/10, thus the score.
Seriously, I haven't seen such a bad adaptation that tries to adapt faithfully to the novels. Indeed, the anime only covers two volumes, and it covers every single story point. However--and I am absolutely shocked--the anime still just sucks so much.
If I had to describe one thing about this show, it'd be cheap. It's not just the obvious telltale signs too, but down to the roots of the show. First of all, is the art. The art is extremely generic. I won't really go into Silver Link, the studio that animated this, but damn does this show's art style look like the most generic and boring isekai anime ever. But it's not just generic, it's also terrible. Each character looks the same, asi…
Read at the sourceshrimpfan92
What you see is what you get. This show revolves around its gimmick that Mia is acting selfishly and childishly to prevent dying again and people misunderstand her and think she’s some kind of mastermind. This moves all of the comedy and plot progression forward, and gets a bit stale by the end. While Mia does get some character development from the relationships she gains, because everything revolves around the premise that Mia happens to do the right thing by accident, she remains largely the same by the end of the show. Normally this wouldn’t matter too much for a strict comedy, but the anime handles its plot seriously enough to where Mia’s ineptitude comes off as annoying when there are high stakes.
It’s not bad, and if the synopsis sounds appealing to you I say go for it, but persona…
Read at the sourceIchUndAnime
I'm into strategy/intrigue anime and have developed a love for these "I'm terrible noblewoman, reincarnated, want to do better" stories as a result. Accordingly, I was looking forward to "Tearmoon Empire".
It's about the crown princess who perishes in the "French Revolution" and is reborn. Thanks to her worn, bloodstained diary, she remembers her last life and wants to prevent her undignified, cruel demise.
I was shocked at how little I liked this anime. After two episodes, I had to force myself to watch the third and it didn't convince me either.
Princess Mia is an idiot who stumbles into one situation after another because of the mystical PLOT, which prevents the downfall of the kingdom and thus also her death. What seemed at least a little intentional at the beginning soon develops in…
Read at the sourcemrfried
There have been a lot of these lately, usually the plot is reincarnated into an Otome Game as the villainess and trying to avoid the doom ending using the knowledge of the game, here however the twist is that the 'villainess' reincarnates back into herself six years before she meets her own doom with nothing but her memories and her diary of the intervening years to help her avoid her fate.
I will say that because this current trope hasn't been overdone, I do find myself enjoying these types of series, the only issue I've had with most of them is that in most cases, they start strong, but then tend to lose their way, usually ending with you feeling unsatisfied with how it ended.
This is in my opinion one of the better entries in the genre, while it doesn't do too much special and certain…
Read at the sourceneonat
The show is really a mixed bag. From the get-go I found it quite hard to believe Mia should be behaving in such a childish and immature way when she returned back to her 12 year-old self. She went through 3 years of horrible suffering imprisoned in horrible conditions before getting killed, yet she still acts like a kid who seems to be trying to avoid death by guillotine the same way a kid tries to avoid eating his vegetables. There is no intense fear or trauma, or anything that would really be ingrained in someone after such long suffering. I’ve been personally told that in the story (light novel?) she has selective memory or slight amnesia after going back in time, but not only does the anime not explain that in any way, it’s very hard to believe that kind of setting when she clearly can…
Read at the source
